The Suppression Paradox: A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Suppression Frequency, Suppression Ability, and Depression

•Suppression frequency has a stronger positive association with depressive symptoms for US than Chinese participants.•Suppression ability has a negative association with depressive symptoms in both cultures•In Chinese sample only, suppression ability partially offsets the effect of suppression frequ...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published in:Journal of affective disorders 2020-09, Vol.274, p.183-189
Main Authors: Chen, Shuquan, Burton, Charles L, Bonanno, George A
Format: Article
Language:English
Subjects:
Asian Continental Ancestry Group
Cross-Cultural Comparison
Culture
Depression
Depression - epidemiology
Humans
Suppression Ability
Suppression Frequency
Citations: Items that this one cites
Items that cite this one
Online Access:Get full text
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
Description
Summary:•Suppression frequency has a stronger positive association with depressive symptoms for US than Chinese participants.•Suppression ability has a negative association with depressive symptoms in both cultures•In Chinese sample only, suppression ability partially offsets the effect of suppression frequency on depressive symptoms.•Future studies are encouraged to directly investigate the cultural differences in contextual demands as it may shed light on suppression across cultures. The habitual use of expressive suppression (suppression frequency) is consistently associated with a number of negative outcomes, but paradoxically, the ability to suppress when there is a situational need (suppression ability) is usually linked to positive outcomes. The two sides of the paradox, suppression frequency and suppression ability, have been found to be unrelated. Given that these findings have emerged in largely western samples, the present studies examined whether the coupling of suppression frequency and ability depends on cultural contexts, and whether this can explain the previously established cultural difference in the costs of suppression frequency. In an initial study, we examined the relations among suppression frequency, suppression ability, and depression in a Chinese sample (Study 1; N = 310), and then, using two new samples, we compared these relations between Chinese and the US samples (Study 2; N = 392). Results showed that suppression frequency was related to depression in two distinct ways. In both cultures, suppression frequency had a direct, positive association with depression. In Chinese culture only, however, suppression frequency also had an indirect association, such that higher suppression frequency was related to higher suppression ability and in turn related to fewer depressive symptoms. Our findings show that suppression frequency is related to suppression ability only among Chinese participants, and can serve as a potential explanation for why suppression frequency is less related to depression in Chinese culture.
ISSN:0165-0327
1573-2517
DOI:10.1016/j.jad.2020.05.126